An average clickthrough rate of 19.61% is considered good for websites holding the top position on mobile within the Science industry during Q1. Conversely, in the Education sector, a benchmark CTR of 32.50% is expected for the same ranking position.
Going only one quarter back the situation was completely reversed. Besides the smaller CTR difference between the two industries (1.54 pp instead of 12.89 pp), the websites ranked first on mobile in the Science market got, on average, more organic clicks than the ones from the Education industry (27.09% vs. 25.55%).
As you can notice, these figures undergo consistent shifts from one quarter to another. The forthcoming analysis of Google CTR changes will offer valuable insights into potential traffic fluctuations, even if your website's rankings and impressions remain consistent.
All searches
At a global level, the change affected only the websites ranked first on desktop queries, which registered a 1.02 pp increase in CTR.
Branded vs. Unbranded
The growth trend in CTR for the websites ranked first on desktop queries was reflected in unbranded queries, too, while for the branded queries the changes weren’t quite significant.
More precisely, for those searches that don’t contain specific brand or business names, websites ranked in the first position on desktop experienced a 1.04 pp boost in CTR.
Search intent
The websites ranked first for informational intent queries (containing words such as what, when, where, how, etc.) recorded a 1.79 pp drop in CTR on mobile devices. As for the desktop queries, while the websites ranked first weren’t quite influenced by the changes, those ranked in the second position registered a 1.07 pp drop in clickthrough rate.
However, when segmented by search intent, the most impacted websites at the top were the ones ranking for location queries (those containing words such as near, nearby, from, directions, route, maps, etc.). More precisely, the websites ranked first experienced a 3.26 pp increase in CTR on desktop and a remarkable 4.20 pp growth on mobile.
Keyword length
Here, while there was no real change for the searches made from mobile devices, the CTR values for the websites ranked first on desktop recorded growth on almost all fronts.
More exactly, for 1-word searches, the increase equaled 1.24 pp, for 2-word queries, the registered boost accounted for almost an entire percentage point (0.99 pp), and for 3-word queries, the increase was 1.22 pp.
Industries
In this section, we'll incorporate search demand data into our analysis to pinpoint the underlying reasons behind potential traffic shifts within various industries, even if the rankings stay consistent.
When there's a simultaneous rise in a website's position clickthrough rates and an uptick in search demand for its industry, it's probable that traffic will increase. Conversely, a decrease in both CTRs and industry search demand could lead to a traffic downturn.
This chapter will be segmented into two separate parts according to the progression of search demand.
A. Industries that experienced an increase in search demand
The websites ranked in the second and third positions in the Careers market experienced a combined 2.17 pp increase in CTR on mobile (1.11 pp for those ranked second, and 1.06 pp for those ranked third). The ascending trend was even higher on desktop, where the website ranked in the first three positions witnessed a combined 5.27 pp growth in CTR (2.41 pp for those ranked first, 1.80 pp for those ranked second, and 1.06 pp for those ranked in the third position).
Coupled with the highest growth of the quarter in search demand (+27.83%), it’s highly probable that the websites ranked in the positions above noticed a spike in organic traffic.
Law, Government, & Politics market had an asymmetrical evolution in CTR in regard to the devices and positions affected in this first quarter of the year. Here, on desktop, the websites ranked first witnessed a 1 pp loss, while those ranked in the third position experienced a round percentage point growth. On the other hand, but on mobile this time, the websites ranked in the first two positions experienced a combined 4.60 pp loss in CTR (2.88 pp for those ranked first, and 1.72 pp for those ranked second).
Simultaneously, during this first quarter, the search demand increased slightly, by +2.11%.
Despite closing the previous year with a drop in search demand, the News industry recovered a bit from this perspective. With an overall +13.48% increase in impressions, the websites ranked first lost 2.18 pp in CTR on searches made from mobile devices.
While people’s interest in travel increased in Q1, as shown by a growth of +20.48% in impressions on our search demand tool, the CTR values experienced contrasting changes this time. Here, in the Travel industry, on desktop, the websites ranked first witnessed a 1.93 pp growth, while those ranked in the second position registered a 2.37 pp loss.
Websites ranked first on mobile searches in the Arts & Entertainment industry recorded a 3.47 pp decline in CTR. On a more positive note, this market registered a +20.31% growth in search demand.
One last market where the search demand increased (by +6.99%) is Pets. Nevertheless, the CTR values went in the opposite direction, at least on mobile, where the websites ranked first registered a decline of 2.78 pp.
Here’s a visual round-up of the changes mentioned in the six industries above:
B. Industries where the search demand dropped
Let’s start this section in force, with the industry with the highest increase in clickthrough rate for a single position: Education. Here, the CTR for websites ranked first on queries made from desktop devices grew, on average, by 6.22 pp, while on mobile, the changes reached a remarkable 6.95 pp growth.
On the other hand, the growth affected the websites ranked second on mobile, as well, which recorded a 1.17 pp boost in CTR, while the industry’s overall search demand decreased by -81.26%.
Despite recording one of the highest declines in search demand of the quarter (-73.41%), there’s still a glimmer of hope for the websites in the Personal Finance industry. Or, at least for the websites ranked first on desktop searches, which recorded a 1.09 pp increase in clickthrough rate.
As for the Hobbies & Interests category, the clickthrough rate for the websites ranked first experienced an impressive 2.44 pp boost on desktop devices and a 1.63 pp growth on mobile. Nevertheless, the industry’s overall search demand went in the opposite direction, decreasing by -3.62%.
The websites ranked first in the Health & Fitness industry experienced a 1.25 pp loss in CTR on mobile. Coupled with a drop of -6.39% in search demand, it’s highly probable that these websites noticed a slight loss in organic traffic.
A similar trend occurred in the Home & Garden industry, where just like in the Health & Fitness market, the very same websites were affected negatively, while the impressions dropped. Here, the websites ranked first on mobile recorded a 1.15 pp decline in CTR, while the industry’s search demand decreased by -19.97%.
It’s time to turn our attention to the first quarter’s highest decline in clickthrough rate for a single position: the Science industry. Here, the websites ranked first recorded a 7.48 pp loss in CTR on mobile.
On the other hand, the decline affected the websites ranked in the second position, as well, which recorded drops in CTR on both desktop (1.80 pp) and mobile devices (2.76 pp). Simultaneously, this market’s overall search demand decreased by -18.74%.
After a quiet quarter (the latest changes date back to Q3 2023) there was some activity at the top of the SERPs on desktop devices in the Business industry. Therefore, websites ranking first on desktop got an average increase in clickthrough rate of 1.18 pp. At the same time, the impressions for this industry recorded a slight drop of -1.82%.
Desktop and mobile CTR values went in opposite directions this time around in the Food & Drink market, for the websites ranked first as follows: on desktop, the growth in clickthrough rate was 1.22 pp, while on mobile, the drop equaled 1.20 pp. Concurrently, the number of impressions for this industry declined by -10.44%.
Last but not least, with an almost insignificant change in search demand ( -0.03%), the Real Estate market recorded a 1.05 pp increase in CTR for the websites ranked first on mobile devices only.
Here’s a graphical representation of the changes mentioned above:
That’s it for…the first quarter
The initial quarter of 2024 witnessed significant fluctuations in clickthrough rates across various industries, for informational, and location-based queries, unbranded searches, as well as for those desktop queries containing up to three words.
These changes may impact your website traffic, underscoring the importance of ongoing evaluation of CTR metrics.
By comparing your website's performance against industry benchmarks, you can uncover opportunities to improve click rates. Additionally, given the unique layout of search engine results pages for each keyword, conducting a detailed analysis to measure your organic CTR for SERP features becomes essential.
And make sure to stay tuned for the analysis of the second quarter, compared to Q1. Until then, stay safe and healthy!
Article by
Dan Popa
Dan Popa is an Online Marketing Strategist at Caphyon. He is passionate about both Online and Offline Marketing and he's always looking for new ways of applying the basic principles of marketing in the fast-evolving SEO field. He's always in the mood to chat about new creative ideas for campaigns, so you can find him on Twitter.
stay in the loop